Tim's Web Log #3
Thoughts and opinions of an opinionated person

Thu, 10 Mar 2005

Rachel Scdoris
Oregon native Rachel Scdoris is currently in Alaska, running the Iditarod sled dog race. Just competing in that race is a remarkable enough achievement, but Scdoris faces an additional challenge: she is legally blind.

Now, I don't want to minimize the challenges she has faced and overcome in her life, and I certainly do not think she should be denied any opportunities that would be provided a fully sighted person. However, there is something about this that bothers me.

To help her get through the race, Scdoris is accompanied by a prompter, riding ahead of her on a snowmobile, calling out directions. That's not fair. One of the big obstacles in the Iditarod is the terrible loneliness caused by the complete isolation one feels when surrounded by hundreds and hundreds of miles of absolutely nothing but snow. Most of the mushers experience hallucinations during the race, some of them severe enough to cause breakdowns. Scdoris will not have to face that. She knows there is companionship available -- another human being within a few feet who can help out in any emergency situation.

I don't care if she never talks to the prompter. I don't care if she doesn't even see the prompter for miles at a time. She knows the guy is there. That is an incredibly important advantage that the other mushers will not have.

I understand that the current results have her well down in the pack (something like 70th out of 75), so there is little chance that this advantange will affect the outcome, but the fact remains that she isn't really experiencing this race in the same way as the other mushers.


# From Jen Lung at Tue Mar 29 07:15:34 2005:
I am a 6th grade teacher with students who follow the Iditarod.  She did not have a man driving a snowmobile ahead of her.  The man working with her was on a dog sled just like her.  He scratched about an hour after her with a very healthy team of dogs.  I am sure she did not experience the race the same as other mushers.  Cover your eyes with vaseline and try navigating dogs on a tough trail while missing the beautiful scenery that other mushers talk about.  Your ignorance fuels my students' ignorance.

# From Tim at Tue Mar 29 09:10:55 2005:
Name-calling does not help your case, and I hope you are not teaching that to your 6th graders.  I am many things, but I am not "ignorant".

The television news reports certainly showed her navigator/assistant on a snowmobile, but the follow-up reports do say that he was on a sled.  It is possible the TV report I saw was from some previous race.

That does not change my position.  She was in radio contact with him at all times, and had the comfort of knowing he was always there, just in front of her.  That is a huge advantage that the other mushers did not have.  It wasn't fair.

# From Don at Fri Apr 1 00:03:39 2005:
Please refer to 4th paragraph of Anchorage  daily News link :

http://www.adn.com/front/story/4493773p-4471662c.html

It says that "Race Officials voted to let her run the Iditarod with help from an assistant on a separate dog sled."

Plus, there are many more important issues in life to worry about that are "Not Fair".  Corporate American Business is not fair in numerous ways.  Let her run the race - don't worry about it being "fair".  Now,  if the Race Officials allowed her to use an Abram's Tank - then, that would not be fair.


Name:


E-mail:


URL:


Comment:


Please enter "blog" here (without the quotes) so I know you are human and not a spam script:


About Me
E-mail Tim
Work info
Personal info
My big dog!
My little dog!
RSS feed

Archives
2010-Jan
2008-Nov
2008-Feb
2007-Oct
2007-Sep
2007-Jul
2007-May
2007-Feb
2006-Oct
2006-Sep
2006-Aug
2006-Jun
2006-May
2006-Apr
2006-Mar
2006-Feb
2006-Jan
2005-Nov
2005-Oct
2005-Sep
2005-Aug
2005-Jul
2005-Jun
2005-May
2005-Apr
2005-Mar
2005-Jan
2004-Dec
2004-Nov
2004-Aug
2004-Jul
2004-Jun
2004-Apr
2004-Feb
2004-Jan
2003-Dec
2003-Nov
2003-Oct
2003-Sep
2003-Aug
2003-Jul
2003-Jun
2003-May
2003-Mar
2003-Feb
2003-Jan
2002-Dec

Categories


Web Sites
P&B company site
Python language site